It all started with a weekend trip to Hyannis Port with their friends and family. After a couple of days of vacationing and just before dinner, Matt took Josh down to the boathouse for a "walk by the water". Matt got down on one knee and proposed to Josh asking for his hand in marriage. Minutes later (and after Josh recomposed himself) their friends and family joined to toast the couple. Then as the night progressed, the celebratory group walked up to the beach house, where Karson Butler Events transformed the backyard into dining al fresco for their friends and family to celebrate the evening.